Announcing a pregnancy can be a really emotional experience for anyone, but it's weighted with more significance if you've lived through miscarriages or lost children in the past.
While some share the news through a series of phone calls or a flashy social media post, a lot of people prefer to kick off the chain of congratulations with an IRL announcement to loved ones. Finding the best time and place to tell the family can be tricky to coordinate, but when everything goes to plan, it can be a memory for the scrapbooks.
In a recent post on the Am I The *sshole subreddit, a mom-to-be asked if she's unreasonable for feeling frustrated that her younger sister announced her pregnancy the same day OP was planning to.
AITA for being upset my younger sister announced her pregnancy first?
I know the title makes me sound like an asshole but please here me out.
To contextualize the situation, OP shared that she's been married 12 years, and during that time she's had six miscarriages, two stillbirths, and two failed surrogacies.
Because OP's husband has felony charges from his younger years, adopting or fostering is not an option for them. Her younger sister, on the other hand, has had three kids in six years with no problems.
I've been married for 12 years and we started trying for kids 2 years in. In the ten years that we've been trying I've had six miscarriages, two stillbirths, and two failed surrogacies. Naturally, my husband and I have been pretty devastated by all of this but try to move through it. My younger sister got married six years ago and now has three kids with no troubles. I try not to be jealous, and I genuinely love her kids and her, but I'm human and every time she announced a baby my heart broke a little more. We can't foster or adopt, my husband has a felony charge from when he was 18. He was stupid but he turned his life around and is a law-abiding citizen now.
After a lot of heartache, OP and her husband stopped trying for awhile, and then gave it one final try this year.
This time they successfully got pregnant and she's already five months along. She wanted to wait past the first trimester to share the news, because telling everyone and losing the pregnancy would trigger past grief.
We had stopped trying for a while but decided to try one more time this year. It took and I'm now five months along. We didn't tell anyone for fear of losing it but our doctors and ourselves are incredibly confident that this will be the winning pregnancy. The one person we did tell was my mom. She was planning my dad's 70th birthday bash and she asked if I wanted to use the party to announce it, since it would make my dad, who adores his grandkids, incredibly happy. I agreed.
When OP told her mom, it was suggested that she tell the whole family at her dad's 70th birthday bash since he loves being a grandpa so much.
However, when her sister arrived OP could immediately tell she was pregnant again. The two sisters celebrated and OP told her sister how excited she was to make an announcement.
The day of the party I'm hiding my belly when my sister and her family come in, and I can just tell looking at her that she's pregnant again. I take her aside and tell her in secrecy that I'm also pregnant. She was happy for me, we danced around, I may have peed a little. I told her we couldn't wait to tell everyone.
A couple hours later, when OP and her husband went to find her dad to share the big news, her sister quickly swooped in.
Couple hour later the party is in full swing, my husband and I find my mom and we go to find dad so we can make the announcement. My sister runs up to my dad and delightfully announces that she's eight weeks along with her fourth child. My dad was so happy, he adores kids and babies. When the excitement died down a little he came up to me, mom, and my husband said, "another niece or nephew for you, Jess, isn't that nice?" I said, "yeah it is, especially now that MY baby will have someone to play with." My dad was happy but, and please forgive me, not as happy as he would have been had I been able to make a big announcement.
When her sister made a pregnancy announcement first, it made OP feel overshadowed and like she lost a special moment.
She's aware that pregnancy in itself isn't unique to her, but given her loss this moment felt especially significant.
When my sister announced I felt crushed. I know I'm nothing special and in the grand scheme of things, who really cares about another pregnant person. But I've got two babies in the cemetery and several miscarriages that lead up to this, and damn it, I just wanted one moment to celebrate. My sister has had three previous moments, I just wanted one. This will probably be the only baby I have. I took my sister aside and explained to her how hurtful it was to have her announce her baby when I've never got to do it before. Basically she told me to get over it and that the world doesn't revolve around me. I told her to f*ck off and we haven't spoken in the week since. I know this is a trivial matter.
When confronted, OP's sister told her to get over herself and that she's being unreasonable, and the two are now currently at odds.
AITA for feeling like she stole my thunder and getting upset?
friendlynea completely understands why OP is upset, but doesn't think the sister was malicious.
Info: when you told her you were pregnant, did you tell her you were planning to announce it at the party?
I am so sorry for everything you have been through. I can't even imagine how strong you and your husband had to be to get through it. And as someone who has had a stillborn, I know the feeling when everyone around you is having babies. You're happy for them and excited, but there's always that part of you that's sad and devastated.
You're NTA for being upset. I would like to think that maybe your sister just didn't know you were planning to announce it that day.
But trust me, you're mum and your dad are probably just as excited for you. My guess is youre thinking that because you're disappointed with how it all went down.
Anyway, congratulations! Stories like yours make me really happy and give me hope for my future. I'm sorry it didn't go the way you wanted, but it's definitely not any less special because you didn't get to announce it the way you want.
Ishdakitty thinks OP's reaction to her sister's announcement dampened the moment for everyone.
I'm picturing this family, excited to hear another grandbaby is on the way, and then older sister snaps "That'll be great for MY baby to play with." I cannot hear OP's words without hearing the snark and nastiness that comes with how she must have been feeling.
How is her family supposed to react? If she got a muted response to her announcement, I think it's likely a result of OP snapping rudely in reaction to her sister announcing first instead of adding to the sense of celebration with her own news. I know I'd have felt awkward as hell.
rhinocerospartayyy asked OP if her sister was aware of the announcement plan, since that greatly paints the situation.
INFO: did you tell her you were planning to announce that day? did your sister see you with your dad and then barge in or did she tell him unaware that you were simultaneously walking towards him to do the same?
OP responded to clarify that her sister didn't overly know her plan, but it was strange she sprinted over to make the announcement and didn't feel out the moment.
I can't say what my sister was thinking when she announced, but she was running up to my father at the moment me, my husband, and my mom came outside. Like, full on sprinting. So, IDK. I didn't outright specify I was going to announce at the party but I did say that I was excited to tell everyone. My sister is not an idiot, I had hoped she would have understood. I know I should have specified but, I was hoping she would, ya know, understand.
3Diglett thinks that OP's sister was being petty and selfish.
NTA
Her saying “the world doesn’t revolve around you” is pretty telling.
She deliberately stole your thunder and announced it without you because she actually thinks the world revolves around her.
dobemomma86 thinks OP's sister was being deeply insensitive about the situation.
NTA... Any reasonable person, especially a close sister and especially one who is a mother and has seen her sister lose baby after baby.... She should have (and let's be honest - probably DID) know you'd planned to announce that day hence the pulling aside to tell in confidence.
You're FIVE MONTHS along... She's 8 weeks. Most docs say not to announce til 12-13 wks due to chance of loss. She could have waited a few weeks, much less a few minutes for you to have a moment. Who knows why she did it but I'd say it was definitely intentional especially how she belittled you. "World doesn't revolve around you"? Of course not, but that's still a very shitty thing to say anyone much less a sister.
FrugalChef13 truly feels for everyone in the situation.
NAH- I cannot imagine what you've been though. I cannot imagine what your entire family has been through. The heartbreak of multiple miscarriages and two stillbirths and two failed surrogacies (and that can mean so many things), it's unfathomable to me. I grieve my own fertility struggles and losses in my own way, and my grief is just a tiny drop in the ocean you're swimming in. I cannot in good conscience call any of you an asshole, I really can't.
All I can offer is my own perspective, as a woman from a large family where you're either one or the other- you get pregnant at the drop of the hat and have 2 or 3 or 4 completely easy pregnancies, or you struggle with miscarriages and stillbirths and birth defects that are "incompatible with life" over and over again. You just keep on hoping one day they'll have a healthy, living baby and you can't do anything to help. It's hard. I never know what to say to my cousins- some of them are just trying over and over again, and some are annoyed that they used two methods of birth control and still got pregnant and they can't really afford another baby but they're Catholic so... There's always babies coming, and some people are happier than others.
In my family, you don't bring a single baby thing into the house till you're a certain point along. It's seen as bad luck (we all know it's silly, but people cope how they cope).
My cousin K, she lost her first during labor and her second in the late second trimester. She got pregnant again about a year later and we all knew, cause hyperemesis gravidarum is pretty obvious when it lands you in the hospital twice in a month. She said "no baby stuff in the house, no one mentions I'm pregnant, no celebrating, no showers, no putting furniture in the nursery, no nothing." She said "I'm just getting fat. One day I'll go to the hospital and get skinny again, and maybe I'll bring a baby home and maybe I won't, so hush your mouth."
So that's what we did. The aunts bought some baby diapers, someone had a crib, someone else had bottles and blankets, and we all had baby clothes to share. We let her cope and have space, and we prepared in the hope that all would go well. That's all you can really do as a future auntie or uncle or cousin or gramma, you just hope.
I know you're hurt and sad and angry. I know you feel like your sister stole your thunder on purpose. I know you're confident that this pregnancy will end in a happy, healthy mom and baby. I really really really want you to be right. But I want to put in your thoughts that while you have two babies in the cemetery, your parents also have two grandchildren there, and your sister also has two nieces/nephews there. Maybe your sister tried to steal the spotlight on purpose, maybe she f*cked up because she had a plan for the party and didn't know you had one too, maybe she's just terrified at the thought of you and your whole family losing another much loved, much wanted baby. Your anger and hurt at your thunder being stolen is understandable, and I hear you. There are no assholes here, and no easy answers.
I really really really hope you and your baby have a safe, healthy pregnancy that ends in a safe, healthy birth and a happy, healthy family.
Hopefully OP and her sister are able to make amends, and the whole family can return to celebrating both pregnancies.