The early and mid 2000s were a prime time for hidden camera shows. We had Ashton Kutcher trolling fellow celebrities with shenanigans on "Punkd," James Murray tricking the public with silly schemes on "Impractical Jokers," and of course the iconic omnipresence of "Candid Camera" - and all the surprised guests it featured.
While most of us know that reality television isn't true reality - there's always a bit of preparation or scripting, it's fascinating finding out where the lines are drawn on each show. Since no two reality shows function the same, the only people who really know what's real and fake are those who've been on set.
Luckily, we don't have to cameo on "Impractical Jokers" or "Divorce Court" to get the juice on what goes down behind-the scenes.
In a popular Reddit thread, people who have appeared on hidden camera shows shared what was pre-planned, and what it was like on-camera.
1. From letterstosnapdrago:
Was picked as a random participant for some MTV show that was filming in my neighborhood. They said it was a game show.
They had me fill out paperwork and made me change my shirt because it had writing on it even though it wasn’t for a product or anything. They gave me a plain black T-shirt. I waited around with other participants for a while, like about 45 minutes. A few people left.
Finally they came over and directed me to walk over to a specific area down the street. I noticed a big residential style trash can with wheels (we have more standard Oscar the grouch types here). It seemed out of place and so as I walked I was kinda looking at it.
Then a guy popped out of the trash can to scare me. I didn’t even react. I just kinda looked at him curiously. At that point a bunch of people came out and someone called cut. The director seemed to be really pissed that I didn’t react well enough. They took me aside, gave me $20 and sent me on my way.
A friend of mine was on cash cab. The whole thing was fake.
They told him he’d be on a reality tv show about food with a hidden camera, but didn’t say which one. Got him to sign a bunch of forms and stuff a week in advance and had him stand at a specific place at a specific time.
There were tv producers standing around and obvious camera crews waiting. Nobody walking by would possibly think it’s a regular cab.
Edit: another friend of mine was on the price is right. The audience members are not randomly selected as they say publicly, they’re screened for TV appeal on the way in.
Well, I kinda accidentally ruined one.
I was walking through a mall when a staff door to my right flies open and this guy is yelling "So who's ready to win 1,000 euro in -" but before he can finish, he SLAMS into me. Neither of us saw each other coming: the camera guy had gone to the left, and this host man has turned himself around to look at the family of five he was leading through the doors. He got right back up and glared at me, the family meanwhile looking pretty worried.
I doubt that made the final cut, but at least I was on camera!
My wife and I applied for and were accepted to do House Hunters but turned it down because it required us to take a week off work to film. Biggest requirement is that you have access to both the place you bought and the place you're moving out of at the same time for filming. So obviously everyone on it already bought their house and are just shown two other random houses by their realtor.
A late night show tried to prank my brother one time. He was a PA at the time out getting coffee for crew members. While he was in the coffee shop, they put a fake boot on his company van and said he was parked illegally. He said the guy who approached him was too obvious though, and my brother didn't buy the act at all. He ended up just taking the fake boot off his wheel, handing it back to the guy, and just driving away. Ain't nobody got time for that.
I was on "Mystery Diners" one time.
It was supposed to be a hidden camera show about the boss of a restaurant hiring undercover detectives to expose bad business operations.
The entirety of the show was fake. The TV show paid the owner of the company to do the show there, the "hidden" cameras in each corner of the restaurant were massive globes bigger then my head with thick cables running to them, we had to train fake employees, even the customers for the entire day were fake.
I was supposed to be the good employee, I was told to greet a table like I normally would, and act surprised when the customer asked me about a promotion I never heard about.
My brothers best friend's family was on Extreme home makeover. They filmed "surprise you're gonna be on TV" scene and the move that bus scene like a crap ton of times till they got the perfect reaction. My dad helped work on the house and he said the camera crew and the hosts were douchebags who were in the way more than anything, they didn't help, and if they tried they screwed stuff up.
I was never found on hidden TV, but a coworker was caught on to catch a predator, in Florida trying to hook up with a supposed 13 to 15 year old female. We live and work in Arizona. He served time, was fired and when his probation was up came back to AZ to beg for his job back. My employer turned him away. I can't imagine showing my face in a place I worked, after such a thing.
Was in Vegas with my wife when we ran into Chris Angel and his crew. Before he really became popular. They asked if we wanted to be on the show. We said sure. We had to wait while they filmed another couple. It was a spider appearing from nowhere deal. We watched as Chris distracted the couple as his producer produced the spider from a bag and slipped it in. We turned around and left.
I wasn't actually on the show but I was at Mountain Creek when Impractical Jokers were filming. Most people just kind of ignored that they were filming but it was extremely obvious as they had set up cameras all over the place all over the walls, as well as having cameramen around following James Murray.
Although they also had people around "encouraging" people that recognized them to put their phones away. It seemed pretty legitimate though because they were trying to get at people who didn't know them.
Edit: https://imgur.com/a/CFLfVxl picture I took of Q from that day, it was also in 2014 when they weren’t as famous as they are now
Was at a resort where they were filming the Bachelor in Paradise and was eating breakfast at the same place a couple was about to be filmed. I watched them look at their scripts and go over their lines. It was faker than I thought it was.
EDIT: Did not think this would blow us as much as it did.
I was in Puerto Vallarta in Mexico which is where they film it.
I go to Puerto Vallarta annually and I remembered meeting a guy on my resort that worked for the show as a technician, he was going to spend 6+ weeks all expenses paid on the resort which is pretty sweet.
I don't know who the couple is.
Lastly, I knew the reality TV was fake but I didn't think there would be scripts, that's like movie fake.
Here’s my sh*tty anecdote about how I could be on some guy’s internet prank show.
I was working at a convention, taking a break when I hear someone play fart sounds from their phone. I look around to see where the sounds are coming from and raise my eyebrow at a guy standing nearby. He keeps making the sounds and I occasionally glance over.
After a while he walks up to me and tells me that he does a prank show on YouTube and asks for a video release to use footage he shot of me reacting to his fart sounds. I give him permission. I was unable to find the show online when I got home, because I forgot his name, so I’m not sure if I ended up on it or not.
My memory on the details is a little fuzzy, but in 2008 I was in Montreal at a park and Just For Laughs Gags was there setting up. I never found the footage again but they set up a bench next to the large pond/lake whatever it was and when someone sat there a bicycle towing a baby carrier would ride by and the carrier would detach and roll into the large pond/small lake, with the rider continuing along like nothing happened.
We saw them set up the area and do some test runs with the bike, the cameras were disguised as a fake water drinking fountain and a fake do not touch electric box. Once they were ready to go the crew made themselves super scarce. Unfortunately we didn't stay long enough to see more than one person get pranked by it.
Set up and testing took *a while* and then nothing happened for a another while, seemed to be waiting for the people in the area to change to people who hadn't seen them set up. We didn't see any aftermath other than someone jumping out to point at the cameras, but talking to people who had seen them do stunts before said they have everyone they trick sign a waiver to allow them to use the footage on the show.
Also fun fact, one of the reasons there is never audio of anyone speaking is because it's a mix of French and English depending on which the person they are fooling speaks.
Edit: There was probably more than two cameras, but we were sitting close to the ones I remember. We saw them roll in the fake objects on dollys, hook in and test the cameras and lock the side panels closed.
Edit 2: TIL the no audio isn’t because of the two languages mixing, it’s because it makes it viewable to anyone regardless of their language. But it conveniently means no subtitles for the mix of French and English that does happen while filming.
Being pranked on a hidden camera show is the strangest feeling - like being dosed on acid without your knowledge and all of a sudden sh*t is going sideways and you wonder if you're legitimately crazy for a moment. It just feel eerie. And my prank wasn't even crazy!
My story: I was broke af and really stoked to be getting a week long gig helping out at a hotel. Turns out I was actually being pranked by a show called Girls Behaving Badly. I show up to work and found out i'd be handing out towels at the pool area. The girl training me seemed normal enough but then she kept "calling dibs" on every dude that would walk by. She asked me why i wasn't calling dibs on anyone. I was just kinda like wtf??? *uhhhh, i dunno? Just here to work. *
Then this hugely obese guy arrived and she kept making jokes that I should call dibs on him. It felt weird. Then she left me alone. As soon as she left the dude started making obnoxious jokes and then things started to feel even more off. It feels like you're in an episode of the twilight zone. I started looking around suspiciously at my surroundings. Then the obese guy asks me to rub lotion all over his back. *Okay something's definitelyyyyy going on* I said no f*cking way.
Suddenly all the people "tanning themselves" by the pool bolt upright and start clapping and startle the sh*t out of me. I scream.
Without much further explanation producers come out and make me do 3 retakes of my reaction. I'm sorta in a stunned daze and go along with it.
Once my retakes are done producers hurriedly usher my still-weirded-out self into a hotel room and like 3 of them are in my face asking "how did you know??" "at what point did you figure it out??" while shoving release forms in my direction. I'm thinking "AM I GETTING PAID FOR THIS SH*T???" (Yes, I was paid one days work at the industry rate for being an "extra" which i think was $120 at the time.)
When I applied for the gig they asked me for 3 personal references - they called my roommate and asked her if I would be cool with getting pranked. She knows I'm easy-going and like an adventure so she said yes.
Yeah, I didn't mind getting pranked but the gig was advertised as being a week long -- so while today it's a fun story I just remember getting in my car and breaking down crying because it was the holidays and I really could have used a week's worth of work.
I never saw the episode to see if my skeptical a*s made the cut!
My roommate in college was on Divorce Court when he wasn’t ever actually married. His ex seen an ad on craigslist about getting help with your relationship and she had responded to it. The producers of the show told her to find someone to join her on the show that she has a history with, so she called my roommate and they flew them both from Chicago to LA for free.
They both were paid $500 for two hours of filming and only had to provide a story and pictures. About six months later the episode aired and we still watch it from time to time on Youtube.
Easily a top 3 college memory for even myself as I watched all unfold.
My grandmother was pranked on Just for Laughs in Montreal. She took my cousins to the zoo and there was a man disguised as a gorilla. She loved to tell the story but passed away shortly after and I don’t think ever saw the footage.
One day we had a small get together and had the TV on in the background, sure enough her episode came on. We all freaked out, mainly me. I still like to look back at the clip from time to time.
Edit: she also mentioned that it was not fake, complete genuine reaction.
I was in one of those "Real People" ads for Chevy. A web one around Comic Con, not a TV one.
Felt weird from the start, figured something was going on when they started talking about a lame superhero named "aluminum man," figured I'd play along for the cameras, revealed it was for Chevy.
I was also in a commercial for Paypal where my credit card was taken away in a retail location. Was cast, accidentally showed a sheet of paper on the day - of that listed out what was going to happen, went in and pretended I had no idea what was going on.
This really only applies to the Northeast. Was in one of my regular lunch restaurants while an episode of Phantom Gourmet was being filmed. This is not some big production TV show, and it's not meant to be dramatic. But I was sitting at the bar less than 10 feet from the 3 or 4 guys that were apart of the episode.
I've watched the show and they weren't faking anything. They legitimately ordered and ate the food they were reviewing, spoke to the owner, and asked the pair of ladies next to them their thoughts. I tried not to gawk or interrupt as I knew it would only get cut. It was cool to see that they weren't embellishing, or misrepresenting the establishment.
I was on one in Portugal, when I was a tourist there. Basically, an old guy pretending to be disabled and require my help, I helped him, then he pretended to be insane. Felt really bad for not being able to help him, then after a minute some lady walked up to me and told me it was for a hidden camera show.
I just felt bad and used, told her OK and walked away with my friend. Not fun in any way - unprofessional people.
EDIT: That being said, I f*cking loved visiting Portugal.
My cousin was a producer for Bar Rescue. Apparently it's generally real, no fake waitresses or anything, and all the skeezy stuff they catch actually happens. Like the employees all know there are cameras. And they still act like that. It's crazy. They would have the cameras up for two weeks - the first week everyone wore a lot of makeup and best behavior. After a week they forget about the camera and do their crazy shit you see on the show.
He did say that part of him and another guys' job was to rile Jon Taffert up. They would do multiple takes with him and egg him on until he was yelling. But other than the (super obvious) product placements they basically let Jon Taffert do whatever he wanted in the budget.
Also - the real bartenders HATED training people. These are people on the top of their game trying to teach rank amateurs. He said those were the hardest to film because the fancy bartenders were often terrible people, and the bartenders they we're teaching were often well-meaning idiots. Not a fun combo.
I was part of the filming of an episode of Impractical Jokers - the episode where they have the questions booth set up in Times Square. I had never seen the show, nor had anybody I was with at the time. I was in high school and visiting the city with a bunch of classmates and it seemed like something interesting, so I went up and asked the guy (who I later found out to be James Murray) a question. He gave me a half smile and then said something like “Alright okay then” and turned away from me. I was confused, but brushed it off and walked away.
About 3-4 years later, I couldn’t fall asleep so I turned on the TV and what happened to be on? Impractical Jokers (which I had never seen before). Not just any episode of Impractical Jokers - that exact episode of Impractical Jokers. It was completely surreal to figure out what was going on, I was almost in disbelief. I remembered there were cameras around, but it was Times Square so it didn’t seem out of place at the time and they seemed to be filming something unrelated anyway.
I didn’t sign a release or anything and they of course never aired my clip, but it was so cool to see it on TV especially not knowing at the time what was going on.
I still wonder to this day what the guys said to him in his earpiece that he wasn’t willing to say to me...
I remember I was at a college party for Thanksgiving; MTV was there filming. I had to sign a bunch of paper work.
Anyways, I was invited to this event by a friend. They never mentioned any filming or what the party was about. Soooo...I got a kids costume that was a full on Turkey costume not thinking much of it.
I go to the party...all the other girls are dressed slutty. Guys dressed in Togas and/or shirtless. I’m the only one in a normal costume and I wasn’t there to drink or dance. Just hang out I thought.
MTV found it hilarious and kept following me all night and kept egging me on to do things. I don’t know if it ever aired or not. Afterwards they gave me a piece of paper, and said they’d email me. I never got an email. Really unsure what happened.
Not quite a hidden camera show, but I was visiting Orange County Choppers in NY once when “American Choppers” started filming. I was in the background of the show when it aired. It was the episode where Jr. went back to the shop to pick up the black widow bike.
We were just looking at the bikes when Jr and Vinny walked through the door with camera crew following in front of and behind them. Jr. At the end Sr. stayed around and took pics and we had to sign agreements to be on TV. Pretty cool experience.
Back in high school (twenty years ago) Candid Camera came to town after our high school band created a bit of buzz by performing a Blues Brothers themed halftime show, complete with all the band members wearing black suits, ties, and sunglasses. We made local news when we partnered with a local Blues Bothers cover band, and they performed a couple songs with us during our homecoming halftime show. Even had the local police escort the performers on and off the football field via police car.
Candid Came a few weeks later, with the cover story of being a local news crew doing a piece on our show. They wanted footage of the band performing a piece of the show for additional B Reel for the story. So they trotted us out early in the morning (band rehearsals started a half hour before first period) and it just happened to be a very cold, very rainy day. In Mississippi.
Unseasonally cold. We were initially told we would be doing our part in the gym, but at the last minute, they changed their minds and we went to the field. None of us were wearing cold weather gear (the suits were very thin, we typically wore two or three pairs of thermal underwear).
Now we are outside. In the cold. In the rain. Not properly attired. We do our routine, and rejoice at the thought of going back inside to the heat.
Nope. The producer guy tells the director that we need to do it again. So we do it again.
The producer guy then requests we repeat the routine another time.
After the third time, the band mob begins to turn. We begin to grumble, as our fingers begin to freeze to our instruments, and we start to lose feeling in our toes.
Then the producer requests we do the routine another time, but this time he requests we increase the tempo. The grumbling turns to swearing.
After about another half dozen attempts to please this producer, who requests we increase the tempo each time, one of our bass drummers, who had Muscular Dystrophy, finally tripped. A couple nearby band mates helped him up, and off the field. The producer had the balls to request yet ANOTHER run through, with the tempo increased to ludacris speed.
Now. Something happens to you and a group of people when you spend the kind of time together and have gone through some of the crap we all went through together. To a man, no one reset for this fool. We all turned to head back to the band hall together. It was at this point that he realized he had lost us, and did the "Smile! You're on Candid Camera!" bit.
We never made it on TV. They couldn't edit the footage enough to cut through all the "F*ck You", "Eat Sh*t", and other random profanity. The Drum Major even dropped trousers and mooned the camera, and everyone was prepared with the single-finger-salute.
On one episode of Undercover Boss, they were at a tilted kilt, and I was there. I used to go there all the time, and this waitress who I had never seen before was walking around with the CEO (dressed to look like a server). She was teaching him how to be a server in a place that only has female servers. Tons of cameras following them around to catch different angles. It really felt staged. The waitress was clearly just an actress hired for this. I watched the clip and saw myself in it in the background.