There are times when a mysterious gut instinct kicks in, and you follow it - all reason be damned, only to later fully realize the danger your brain helped you escape. In these instances, it can be incredible to realize just how much our intuition acts as a protective force.
However, there are plenty of times we feel a gut urge and press on despite our body's warning signals. Sometimes escaping is far harder than pressing through the anxiety, and other times we simply don't trust our instincts. Of course, if you stick around long enough you'll find out why that gut feeling cropped up in the first place, and it's usually not great.
In a popular Reddit thread, people who had a bad gut feeling about a situation but stayed anyway shared what happened.
In 5th grade my math teacher made me and another girl stay after school. He said we did too well on the test. We must have cheated. I always got a weird feeling around him, but when it was just him and us, he was actually smelling our hair. When I finished my test, he told me to leave.
There was no way that I was going to leave him alone with the other girl. I told him my dad said I had to walk home with the other girl. The teacher said I was lying. I was, but I told him to call my dad and tell my dad that he thought his daughter was a cheater and a liar. My dad was super friendly but built like a grizzly bear. He let me wait for her to finish the test.
I had the opposite happen - something very wrong was happening but I was oblivious, and it worked out great.
My friend and I were buying a quarter pound of weed together. We were getting it from a guy my friend knew, but didn't know very well. We went to his apartment to pick it up.
Now, I'm probably a little bit on the autism spectrum, but because I'm from a time where you only got that diagnosis if you were non-verbal, I was "emotionally retarded" and just taught myself habits to seem normal. One of them is "maintain eye contact even if it makes you uncomfortable." This is important.
When we get there, the seller isn't alone, he's got a couple of kinda scary gangsta-looking guys with him. We sit across the table from them and my friend hands him the money. Then the guy chuckles and says "How about you two just leave the money and the weed here?"
I'm bad on reading people, I just maintain eye contact and imitate what I see as a jocular mood, I laugh and say "I think my friend would rather take the weed with him." The guys look at each other a second, then he says "OK" and gives us the weed.
We leave and I notice my friend is white as a sheet and he says "Those guys were going to rob us!" I thought he was being racist and told him they were just joking around, he shouldn't have worried like that.
"Didn't you see the gun?"
Uh, no. I was focused on maintaining eye contact so I didn't look like an autie. Apparently, the guy had pulled a gun after being handed the money. They thought I laughed at their robbery attempt and called their bluff.
I got invited to a party by some random guy I met outside a club, I went to said "party" with him as I was drunk and thought "Sure, why not?", this entailed going to a run-down house in a Council Estate (the UK equivalent of a Project I guess), to enter the house we had to climb in through a window where there were five people sat in a circle made of half-broken chairs and a moldy couch. After entering the window the guy locked it behind him, it was at this point I instantly felt sober again and realized that something was wrong.
That's when the Crack Cocaine and Heroin came out, a woman who was part of the circle who apparently owned the house started telling a story about how her husband had hung himself in the stairwell, her kids had been taken away and that she kept a sharpened screwdriver under her pillow in case "they" came for her.
I was well past wanting to leave at this point, I didn't have an escape though and my nervousness showed, that's when paranoia set in within the "circle", the guy who had brought me there had become incredibly tense, the slightest noise and he would flip out. He stood by the curtains peeping through mumbling to himself about the police watching him. I had to prove I wasn't wearing a "wire" at this point.
Before long however the drugs began to run out, this made the paranoia be temporarily forgotten. I saw a chance here and said I had money and I could buy more drugs, the guy said he would book a taxi for us to go in.
About 15 minutes later a taxi turned up, he unlocked the window and I jumped out first and slammed it shut behind me, ran as fast as I could towards the taxi, jumped in the front seat and just shouted "DRIVE!, DRIVE!" to the taxi driver who took off down the street and to the safety of home.
Closest I've ever felt to being murdered.
When I was a teenager I was best friends with a girl who had an older brother who had mental health issues. This led to him also drinking a lot and generally being a dick.
One night we were hanging out in her basement and he came home drunk. As soon as I heard him coming down the stairs I knew it was going to be bad.
He walked into the room, looked at us and said “ What are you b*tches doing down here?”
My friend had a big shepherd/ chow mix and the dog immediately got up and stood between him and us growling.
My friend yelled for her dad and that set her brother off. He lunged at her and the dog grabbed him by the arm. Suddenly I was trapped standing on a couch, up against the wall.
Her brother is on the ground kicking at the dog. The dog is clamped down on his arm and not letting go. My friend is next to me screaming for her dad.
Dad rushes in, tries to separate them to no avail. Her Mom had called the cops from upstairs ( not the first time ) and they show up.
I sh*t you not, the second the cops came the dog let go on his own and stood in front of my friend again. Cops arrest her brother and her dad drives me home. I never went over their again unless she could promise me he wouldn’t be there.
I was hiking down a trail and I felt like I was being watched. I've read a lot of stories about people going missing in the woods, so I was hyper-aware of every little thing. Instead of going down this one path, I turned around and walked back. I still felt like I was being watched, so I power up my blue tooth speaker, plug in my hiking mp3, and blast some heavy music. A few minutes later the feeling passes.
A day later I heard someone was attacked by a mountain lion on the trail I was going to hike on.
Not me; my mom. Dad was going to Greece on a golf and gambling trip. He went on these trips occasionally, and always came back a winner. Came home from one with about $5K in 1975. He was packing his suitcase the day before the trip when my mom just straight up told him not to go. His friends had all canceled out for various reasons, so he didn’t know anyone who was going. She’d never done that before; she wasn’t controlling at all. They talked for a minute, and dad got on the phone and canceled. The plane he would have been on crashed into a mountain in Greece. No survivors.
The family all visited my grandparents, and I always took that time to be rowdy outside with my cousin. We played games inside all day until they told us to play outside. Walking around at night with my cousin, we tried to come back to the house and turns out we got locked out, as it was like 12 and they thought we were in bed. We had his yellow lab, Yoshi, walking with us. They lived pretty deep in the country, so his dog was used to coyotes, bears, etc. I got this awful feeling in my chest, mentioned it to my cousin who just said "Yoshi isn't acting weird, so everything is okay!" I trusted that for the most part, but knew Yoshi could outrun us and we really didn't have a house to bolt back into in case something happened.
We kept walking until I nearly tripped on Yoshi who was just frozen and whimpering. Her tail was between her legs, and she was staring at this huge bush. The feeling I had in my gut hadnt left me, and I just panicked and stared into the bush. I heard a rustle and Yoshi started barking like crazy, before growling. My cousin and I took that queue to take off running back towards the house. I heard Yoshi yelp but we kept running.
Whatever it was didn't follow us, and after about 5 minutes Yoshi came running back to us. She didn't have any scratches on her, but it scared the shit out of me. After we calmed down, I remembered my Grandma telling everyone she could have sworn she saw a Mountain Lion in her garden a few days ago. They were in Oklahoma, so no one took that seriously as a Mountain Lion that far into OK was pretty uncommon. A week or so later, it was all over the news that there was a Mountain Lion in the area. It had been hit and killed a few miles from where we were. I am positive that the awful feeling I had was us being stalked.
I was walking home from the library in college and decided to dip into the bar to see friends. It was about midnight/1am when I left the bar, maybe after one drink, put my backpack back on and decided to call my brother who was three hours behind to walk me home. As we were chatting, I was getting into the more residential part of campus. Few people. Dark streets. And a guy starts walking along the other side of the road from me. I just barely notice. It’s a big two lane rd and he was about five feet behind. I sped up, slowed down, and he matched pace.
“[brothers name] I have to get off the phone and call the cops, a guy is following me” I said as loudly as I could.
The guy f*cking SPRINTS away as I hang up on my brother.
Being 20, I then decided it was stupid to call the cops if the guy was already gone, went back to Main Street and found a sober guy, and asked him to walk me home. Luckily, it worked out. My brother called eight times to make sure I was okay.
There was a string of stabbings on campus that semester and I wish to this day I’d called the cops.
My old boss was an...interesting guy. He came from a rough part of town and had a bunch of tattoos that really made him look scary but he was actually a nice guy. I asked him about his massive chest tattoo which led him to a story about his younger brother, John.
John was a pretty gentle guy but he started hanging out with blokes from his home town that weren't exactly right in the head. One night they all hanging around drinking, as they did most nights when one of the blokes breaks out some meth, John politely declines and just continues drinking. The energy was getting really weird, guys breaking windows with their bare fists, bleeding all over the place, verbal abuse being hurled, just an all-round wonderful atmosphere.
At one point someone broke out a tattoo gun and started doing home jobs. John really wanted to leave but couldn't because he was quite drunk so he had to stay. Someone ended up spiking his drink so while he was blacked out one of the guys tattooed a swastika on his forehead.
My cat died.
I was away for a week, in another country. I never usually worry about my pets like that, but two days in I was finding myself thinking about my cat more and more and being increasingly concerned about him. Few days in I was having dreams of me going back home in a rush. Instead, I stayed and thought I was projecting the stress of spending the week in an unknown place with people I didn't know a lot yet, and just missing my cat.
Now that cat had come to me from the street, so whenever I left for a few days that's where he'd spend his time. He would only respond to my call but not my friend's so I had no one to send to check on him. When I finally came home I just rushed to all his spots and called for him.
I did that almost every 2 hours when I was not working, for 3 days, including at night. Found him 3 days later, hardly breathing, but walking. Took him to the vet in a rush. Turns out he had cancer and the tumor pushed against his lungs etc. In the past week, something had broken and was filling his lungs with liquid. Had to put him down. I'm just glad I found him and he didn't die alone on the street.
At a night out with a bunch of guys from my old school, one of us gets in a fight with three guys. I sat back near enough to make sure nothing develops and one of their guys joins me. He strikes up a conversation and very quickly tells me he's a Neo-Nazi, he even showed me his tattoos of a swastika and the Waffen SS emblem. It was very clear why he was telling me this because I happened to be the most Aryan looking person there.
He ended up telling me everything from how he got into the cult-like ideology to all the different minorities that he hates. One of the guys I was with thankfully noticed and gave me an excuse to leave once the situation had calmed down
Altogether a very interesting night.
My Ex-Boyfriend. It had been my first relationship in a while. Early on I started to get the feeling that he was lying about things, but it was only little things. Like he’d say he had some childhood illness, or had ran into Ariana Grande at a coffee shop. I tried to brush off the thought that he was making things up, because who would lie about random things.
I stayed with him another 4 months, then realized he was also lying about drug addiction, stealing my money I was giving him for rent and not paying our bills. So I probably should’ve trusted my gut and left sooner.
I used to work at a theme park as a food and beverage supervisor (this was about 10 years ago).
I knew the place like the back of my hand because I grew up in the area and went a lot as a kid, and had been working there about 3 years.
During the quiet periods of the day we would take it in turns to go for a "cigarette break", our nearest break area was past a nearby rollercoaster. On my way back from one break I stop mid-stride and look down at this coaster going under the path. "That didn't sound right" I think to myself. I check my radio is tuned in, and press on back to my food outlet.
20 minutes pass and I've forgotten about this when there is an almighty thud, the lights flicker and in less time than it took to check the fryer settings were ok my radio lights up, chaos on the waves.
I hear amongst the chaos "Echo 4, code 11, section 8" which roughly translates to "watsis-name, serious incident, emergency service access only, section 8." I respond "Received, on it."
We shut everything down and start redirecting customers around the area, that rollercoaster had crashed, 2 people died and 3 are now permanently disabled.
That turned out to be a rough day.
I was living with a friend and her family. She and I were besties through high school but had grown distant over time. She started hanging out with a different girl and got heavy into drugs. She was going out with that girl and I usually would tag along to take care of her, but that night I had a funny feeling and decided to stay home. In the middle of the night her mom came in my room and said they were in an accident. My friend was in a coma for weeks and has been suffering from debilitating diseases ever since. The other girl had to have a hip replacement. When I saw the pictures of the car I knew I would have died. The whole rear end was wrapped around a pole and crumpled.
To this day, if I have a gut feeling, I listen to it.
I got this feeling on my wedding day to my now ex-husband. Getting my hair & makeup done, putting on the big white dress, listening to how excited everyone was, and the entire time I felt white and sick to my stomach. It was like a burning ball inside me, and I felt cold all over. I kept wanting to hide, and I remember my Dad jokingly saying "We can still make a run for it!" and I wish now I'd of taken him up on it. Not even three months after the wedding, he started picking out what I could wear (you shouldn't be wearing pants, women should wear skirts & dresses!), complaining that I wasn't working TWO jobs instead of just one, and not ever letting me out of his sight when I was home from work (I couldn't even walk to the mailbox alone).
A month or so after that, when I'd had enough and started pushing back, he attacked me and started hitting me, right in front of his brother. I remember begging his brother to help me, and instead he sneered and said "Women like you get what you deserve", and when I yelled that I would call the cops, my husband said "Go ahead, I have many cop friends." The very next day I made a phone call to an old school friend telling him my address and that I would be at the end of the road at a certain time. When my husband was outside working on his boat, I threw a few clothes into a bag and ran.
Filed for divorce and never looked back. Ended up working two jobs (haha) and living with my grandmother until I could get back on my feet. Listen to your gut ladies. It might save you a lot of bruises and maybe even your life!
I worked with a girl when I was 18. She was 4 years older than me, and we came from the same small hometown so knew some of the same people. I quickly understood she was not a great person. Narcissistic. Loved to pit people at work against each other by spreading rumors. Backhanded compliments. Dominated every conversation by turning into something about herself. You probably know the type. She didn't like me because I ended up explaining her behavior to our boss after she tried [and failed] to get me fired over a rumor she created.
She didn't last long, thankfully. People caught on, and they knew me well enough to trust that I'm a decent person in that regard.
Fast forward to my later-twenties, back in my hometown. She walks into a bar with my friend. We are awkwardly polite. The night wears on. Drinks. We get to talking and are actually laughing together. It seems like the past is distant. I say I'm going to leave. She looks directly into my eyes and asks if she can come with me.
It was like looking into the eyes of a demon. Every hair on the back of my neck and forearms. Heart rate increased. Cold sweat and the blood drained from my face. But, drunk me, severely lonely from previous years, thinking only of that night's chemistry, said yes. Told myself it was just the anxiety of such a physically attractive woman asking to come home with me.
We ended up dating for almost a year. I have never been more physically, psychologically, or emotionally abused, cheated on, and just destroyed inside. It was severe. My cat's hair started falling out from the stress in the home [he's been a happy, healthy chonk before and after, don't worry]. I won't go into details. But, it was ugly. I was so turned around as a male abuse victim that I had been gaslighted into thinking I was an abuser.
I finally got out, but had to do it alone. With narcissistic abusers, they tend to look for people they can use, that have something, that are unique, stand out, etc. People with potential. I made myself seem thoroughly "pathetic" [what a person like that would think is pathetic], and she casually moved away and found a new victim.
We still shared some friends and she had convinced most of them that I was a bad person. But in time her nature hurt all of them, and while I had moved on and made new friends, they slowly trickled back into my life and related their own horror stories of her.
Ultimately I became stronger and grew in many ways from it, and can even trust, but I'll always have to struggle with thinking no one is ever interested in me so not picking up on it, and confusing boundaries/self-respect for hurting my partner and potentially causing a serious altercation.
That night in the bar I should've just left. Every sense in my body told me to get away from her. But I stayed.
In my 30s, my husband was having an affair and I was sick of staying home alone, so I went to a dance club in Boise by myself.
I had a fantastic time and met a friendly couple, James and Tammy, ended up spending most of the night with them laughing, dancing, joking. Just really fun, open people.
We shut the place down, and out on the sidewalk Tammy says, "Want to go for pancakes?"
"That's a great idea! I'm starved," I said. "My car's around the corner. Should I just follow you to the restaurant?"
"No, don't do that! We'll give you a ride, then bring you back," said Tammy.
"Thank you!" I said. "I'm worn out from all that dancing, haha."
As soon as I get in the car and it pulls away from the curb, I get this sense of dread.
Just a few blocks down the road, James says he wants to pick something up at their apartment, and asks if it's okay if we stop off there for a minute. I'm ignoring my warning bells, still hoping that everything's okay, don't want to ruin a great night by freaking out unnecessarily. They're both still super casual and friendly, so I say, "Okay..."
We get to their apartment, which is really low rent and scummy, and my alarms are getting louder.
"I'll just wait in the car while you get your thing," I said.
Tammy stays, too, and we talk about this n' that, and I start to relax again. There's no pressure coming from her, she genuinely seems delighted to have made a new friend.
"Let's go check on James," she says after a bit.
As soon as I walk through the door, I know I'm in trouble. I'm miles from home in an unfamiliar area, no friends in town and my husband's God knows where with his girlfriend. Did I have a phone? Was the battery dead? I can't remember.
Tammy's between me and the only door, and James is on the sofa watching TV. She offers me a drink, which I decline, then goes to fix herself one.
"Are we staying here?" I ask. "Let's go to the restaurant."
"You bet! I just want one drink, then we'll go."
All this time, Tammy seems great, but James is silent, staring fixedly at the TV, all tense and excited, but trying not to show it. I'm getting super weird, scary vibes from him and this whole situation.
"Do you party?" Tammy asks brightly.
I'm distracted and have no idea what this means, so I say, "I guess."
She sets up some cocaine on the coffee table and she and James have a toot. I've never seen cocaine in my life. I can't believe what I've gotten myself into. I look away from the coffee table toward the TV and finally realize that James is watching gangbang pornography.
I stand up and announce that I'm going to call a cab.
"Oh, don't! Do you want to go?"
"Yeah," I say faux-apologetically. "I'm just really tired." I start walking for the door.
"We'll take you back. Don't pay for a cab, honey. We'll drive you."
I don't remember how she convinced me to get back in the car, but she and James ended up driving me back to the bar and giving me a friendly wave as they drove away.
I think it was an honest misunderstanding: they thought they'd found a willing third, and if I wasn't down with a threesome, that was perfectly okay. And, cocaine was just a normal Saturday night, I guess.
But, man...when I recall turning to face that TV screen, my heart still drops into my stomach. I always, always trust my instincts now.
I was on a camper van trip up the East Coast of Australia and stopped at Bondi for a few nights.
On our last morning there, my friend had some work to get done on his laptop, so I decided to head out for a surf by myself to kill a few hours.
No one else was surfing, the water was murky and anyone that's surfed knows you can start to get a feeling the water is a little 'sharky'.
I left the water unscathed and told my mate about the eerie feeling I'd had. We both headed back to our home towns, only for him to tag me in a news report about a guy that had been attacked while surfing alone at that exact spot one week later.
Have had a few other 'encounters' in that part of the world and every single time you get a bit of a feeling in your stomach beforehand.
I have always listened to my instincts.
One one occasion a fellow detective and I were hunting a bail Jumper in Pennsylvania. We got a contact who gave us a solid lead and told us where to find our guy. For $50 he would also lure the bail Jumper to the one and only gas station in town. We paid the guy, gave him a time to make it happen. It didn't sit right so not being complete f***king idiots, right after we paid our mole, we told the guy that we skip out town for a few hours.
In reality, we went out of town, made sure the mole saw us go out of town and then we doubled back in another way and set our self up on a bluff overlooking the gas station. About thirty minutes before show time, the locals with their guns showed up and started to hide around the place. The bail jumper didn't show up with them. We noticed our mole was always looking in the same direction when he was on the phone.
Ten minutes prior to the time we given our mole, we decided it was not in our interest to go into town. We called out mole and told him we were running 20 minutes late and to sit tight. We on a hunch went and snuck up on the ridge where the mole was looking and found our bail jumper. We got him before he could alert anybody. After we got him in the car and was heading out of the area, he asked how we heard about the ambush.
Told him nothing. Just let him ramble on.
Coming home from a holiday and got into a cab to take us to the airport, immediately I got a gut feeling of "something is going to go very wrong" as we were traveling a big storm broke out so I was thinking "it must be that, we're going to crash because of the storm" but no.
Arrive at the airport with no drama but still the feeling of something bad won't go away. As we walk into the airport I look at the departure board and see our flight has been canceled, my immediate feeling was one of relief and the feeling of dread disappeared immediately. Like "ahh that was the problem".