Even the most amicable of divorces can get complicated in court, so it's hardly surprising that messy divorces often fan out into in long-winded and absurd scenarios.
While legal costs are high, it's hard to put a price on the satisfaction of watching your ex grovel for their favorite piece of furniture, and winning is more important to some divorcees than the actual value of the prize.
Obviously, it's more emotionally healthy to get on with proceedings without getting needlessly petty, but stories of ridiculous behavior tend to be more memorable than mature, cut-and-dry situations.
In a recent Reddit thread, divorce lawyers shared the most ridiculous things couples fought over, and it's a stone cold reminder that love can indeed turn to hate.
Took the couple two hours to decide who would get the groceries left in the fridge. Estimated value of the groceries was around $40. Two hours of my time, opposing counsel time, and mediator time added up to about $1,000. It all came down to a Costco/Sam's Club sized jar of peanut butter. (Who keeps peanut butter in the fridge?!)
Our case fell apart over a massage chair.
They had two kids.
Couldn't let go of the damn chair.
I had a couple arguing for three hours over who got the kids on Christmas day, only to discover at the end that they were both Jewish.
I had another woman who said that her husband drained $60K from their community bank account to pay for a sex change operation that he never told her he was planning to do.
I was a clerk for a law firm in Marin County. The husband grew weed in the house. The town was supportive and even let him redo his electrical panel to accommodate his crop. Long story short, in the divorce, she demanded half of the weed proceeds. Today it doesn't seem like a big deal, but 12 years ago I was shocked to see that in a court document.
My dad was a divorce attorney for some time. He said people would argue over $150 patio furniture for hours on end at a $300/hr rate (each side).
It's not about the patio furniture, it's about sending a message to your b*tch of an ex-husband/wife.
I had a case where the estranged wife was calling my client's employer repeatedly, accusing him of theft and other white-collar crimes, to try getting my client fired.
The thing is, the children were with her, and she was also demanding child support. Which is based on his income. For the job from which she was trying to get him fired.
(Fortunately, the employer was onto her BS and my client wasn't let go.)
The ex-wife hid his artwork (works he had purchased long before the marriage) and in mediation she tried to sell it back to him.
Not necessarily a crazy divorce story, but my dad is a lawyer and his friend has been married three times so my dad has been his divorce lawyer twice and his best man three times.
9. From MSK7:
My now ex-stepmother was getting an 80/20 settlement and refused to agree until the agreement was revised include a bag of old beer can koozies and a dry-rotted pool float. She was crazy which is why dad was paying her to go away.
I'm not a lawyer, but this is a story about my uncle and it's quite brilliant.
My uncle has been a lifelong Videographer and still works to this day as a news photographer. During the early to late 90's he stopped shooting news and started shooting freelance. This was before everyone and their mom (and their moms) had a camera/editing software/whatnot. Eventually he became a sought after photographer.
In the 80s when he was working as a news photographer he met and married a reporter/news anchor of which he would go on to have 2 children with. After leaving the news business to freelance he decided to start a video editing business with his wife. That went extremely well for a while and they were making money hand over fist. He would be asked to shoot for channels such as Food Network and HGTV, DIY, etc and then edit it into the show. She would work as the middle(woman) for his clients and as bookkeeper.
Eventually she would turn out to be a secret substance abuser and adulterer and their marriage ended in divorce. At this point my uncle was making a couple 100k a year with their business. She decided to sue him for alimony (mostly because he was worth a good chunk of change) but also because she helped him build his business. Her demands were ridiculous, something like 75% of the business for the next so many years or something crazy. My uncles lawyer was afraid she was going to win because she had played such a big role in building the biz.
Fast forward to court day, her lawyer stands in front of the judge and lists off what she wants in the divorce. Once he is finished it's my uncles turn. He blindsides her and offers to give her 100% of the business. The judge and both lawyers are confused and ask him if he is sure. Without him shooting and editing there is no business. So basically she would be left with a hell of a lot less than she asking for by asking for X amount of profits.
The judge reasoned that his offer was fair and that she could take it or leave it....she was pissed, her lawyer was pissed and she ended up getting nothing haha.
Tl;dr My uncle started a biz with his wife. She turned into a cheating drug addict. Divorce. She wanted x percent of profits from biz in divorce. He offers her the entire business (total awesome dick move). He is a photog/editor so she can't do sh*t with biz because she isn't a photog/editor. She gets nothing.
I was in a mediation where it took the couple an hour and a half to split their personal property, retirement accounts, real property, and custody of their 6 month old son. The rest of the day, about 4 hours, was spent arguing about how to split the time with the dog. For the kid they just put, "as agreed upon by the parties" but the dog had a strict calendered schedule working out holidays and strict pickup/drop off times. I was ashamed to be a part of that unbelievable display.
Not a lawyer but I work in a law office...we had a guy who cheated on his wife transfer all of his money (slowly over time) to his girlfriend before the wife found out about their affair and file for bankruptcy to avoid having to give his now ex-wife anything in the divorce.
Not a divorce attorney but I clerked for a judge that handled divorce cases. We had a couple that were both lieutenant colonels in the Air Force.
They had one daughter that was about 11 or 12. Both had graduate degrees and were generally intelligent people. Well the husband had an affair and things went sour with the relationship. The daughter was at that age when her relationship with the mother was starting to get a little strained and she mentioned how she wanted to stick with her dad because he was about to be stationed elsewhere and the parents would be going their separate ways.
The mother absolutely freaked. The first thing she did was go to the local police department and claim the father had been molesting and raping the daughter. They investigated and couldn't find any evidence so they dropped the case. The mother still furious then goes to the Air Force Office of Special Investigations and reports the same thing. The Air Force then suspends the husband from duty and conducts their own investigation, same result no evidence of wrong doing and the case is dropped.
The mother then goes to the next state over where the husband is about to be transferred and contacts the local police there with the same story about molestation and rape. They of course do their own investigation but same result, case is dropped
Of course this whole time the daughter has been interviewed a dozen times by psychologists, various therapists, the police, the Air Force, and who knows else. The daughter is straight up traumatized by this. People constantly asking her if her dad had been touching her/raping her and so forth. Not to mention the harm it did to her father's career. He was basically screwed from any possible promotion just because of the allegations. As well as the fact that infidelity in the military is a big no no. But that was his own doing.
Well once word of all this gets back to the judge he is furious. He's a former Air Force Jag and still has contacts in the ranks. Well anyway the couple comes in front of him one day for a hearing and he outright tells her she better stop this behavior or he's going to hold her in contempt of court for the maximum amount of time he can lawfully hold her in a cell, contact the DA and recommend the filing of charges, contact her Air Force superiors and recommend reprimand to the fullest extent possible, and basically anything and everything he can do within his power.
It was one of the most messed up things I've seen during my relatively short experience in the legal world.
When my parents got divorced, my dad had written in the divorce decree that my mother could not make any religious decisions for me, including regular church attendance, baptisms, etc. My mother was raised Mormon and my father was pretty adamant that I would not be raised in that religion too.
Not a divorce lawyer just someone that has gone through a child custody battle and I had to tell my one great story under oath. Sit through this one Reddit. I can't make this sh*t up.
My ex and I had broken up and she decided to get an apartment 30 minutes away from where our apartment was. It's probably for the best so we'd never run into each other in public.
My ex is a 1st grade teacher and found a school to work for on that side of town. My daughter went to school there too, just to make it easier on her mother. I'd drive there and pick up my daughter from school every single day during the week because I work at 5am and got off at 1:30pm. I became good friends with all of the stay at home moms and would talk with them everyday after school while our kids ran off their energy on the playground. On my days off, I'd drop her off and just hang out on that side of town and get to try new restaurants, find new comic book shops, etc.
On one particular day, I decided to try Wee Man's Chronic Tacos for lunch. Now, what they don't tell you about Wee Man's Chronic Tacos is that you need to be within 30 minutes of a toilet after you eat it. I was on my way to get my daughter and I felt like I had to fart really bad. I just casually looked around and let loose in the car.
It was at this moment that I knew I had made a terrible mistake. Yes, Reddit...I sharted my pants 30 minutes from home, 10 minutes before I had to pick my daughter up from school. I had a simple decision to make: Go up there and get her anyway or make something up and come back later. I checked myself out and thankfully it didn't show through my jeans so I waited in my car until I heard the bell ring.
I went up there quickly and took my daughter aside: "Sweetheart, this is really embarrassing. Daddy had an accident. You can't play with your friends today. We need to go." Like a trooper, she understands and we leave.
Now, I told you that story to tell you this story. I left out one major detail above. The routine was: I'd pick my kid up, she'd play with her friends, her mother would come out to the playground and see her for a little while and then leave. On this particular day, I broke the routine. On the ride home, my phone is going off like crazy. My phone was on silent and needless to say, I wouldn't have answered it anyway. I get home and I have 20 missed calls all with voicemails.
Fast forward to our custody hearing. I've got 2 lawyers, she doesn't have 1. Without getting into too many details, it generally isn't going very well for her. She's desperate, really really desperate to make me look like an unfit parent. Representing herself while I'm on the stand, asks about what happened on that particular day. The day I kept her daughter away from her.
Reddit, I looked at my lawyers who I also had to tell this story because I saw this coming. They smiled and gave me that, "Well, go on." look. I had to tell the story about how I shit my pants after eating Wee Man's Chronic Tacos to a judge, a bayliff and a court stenographer. Mid-way through this story, the judge goes from looking at me with this piercing glare to covering her mouth trying soooo hard not to burst out into laughter. Seeing how well received my story was, my ex had no further questions. The judge ended my getting off the stand with "Well!... Now that that's on public record." I froze. "THAT'S ON PUBLIC RECORD?!? Oh man."
And that ladies and gentleman is why I tell this story now. If you were to look up my court case, there is an official version of this story somewhere on public record. I hope this is the kind of thing you were asking for OP. :D
I was a clerk for a family court judge. We had a woman try to get an injunction to keep the father from taking the daughter on a trip to Disney world to play in a concert. It was sad.
This is a true story and it happened in New Jersey. Guy getting a divorce becomes suspicious and insanely jealous that his separated wife is having an affair. He secretly follows her to a bar and waits outside in his car. She comes out many hours later in the dark and follows another car to a house. Husband follows her, staying back, and parks down the block.
He gets out, sees the house her car is parked at, and goes around into the backyard. He's sneaking around looking in windows and finally opens a sliding glass door and enters the house. His wife and the guy she is with hear him moving around, lock the bedroom door, and call 911. He starts pounding on the bedroom door and shouting at his wife, and then the cops kick in the front door. The cops get everyone downstairs to sort this out. That is when the guy realized for the first time his wife was sleeping with his own divorce lawyer.
(The lawyer got in lots of trouble. Definitely one of the most entertaining ethical board decisions of all time.)
One of my uncles' ex-wives actually hired a hit man to kill my uncle so she could collect his life insurance. The hit man was actually an undercover cop. She did 4 years for the crime.
EDIT:
Okay so this was back in like 2000 or around then, but basically my uncle and his wife were in a rocky relationship and the end seemed inevitable. Anyways, we all knew they were fighting, and we all knew that the wife was pretty crazy (she isn't in our bloodline).
So one day my mom was at work and she sees this story on the front page of a newspaper about how someone with her same last name was going to be murdered by his ex-wife. She read it and realized that the person was indeed her brother.
It turns out that the ex-wife had been talking to an undercover cop for like 2 months, trying to figure out a way that she could kill her husband and not be traced. The cop obviously had a case going, but the problem was, there wasn't really any evidence at the time that was enough to put her away, or even charge her. So he kinda kept it going until she was being really serious about it.
Fast forward a couple weeks, and the cop told his buddies at the station what was happening. They show up and my uncles doorstep and they break the news to him. The only evidence that could actually do any damage to her was if she actually paid him money when it was done. What they ended up doing was taking my uncle out into a field, putting makeup on him, making it look like he was murdered, and photographed. Some CSI shit right here.
So the cop brings her the pics, and she pays him and he arrests her on the spot. It turns out all she wanted was his 150000+- dollar life insurance and custody of the two kids. 4 years of jail time seems pretty steep for just that if you ask me.
Not a divorce lawyer but my sister just went through a nasty divorce. It sounds like a movie you would see on LIFETIME. They split up after 28 years of marriage because he fell in love with a lesbian stripper half his age. He emptied their savings and borrowed against their 401k so the lesbian could start her own lesbian bar which was bankrupt after 6 months. There are many more sordid details which I'll go into if anyone is interested.
EDIT More Details...Since there's some interest. First of all, my now ex-brother in law is the least likely guy to do something like this. Imagine Mr. Cleaver (From Leave it to Beaver) cheating on Mrs. Cleaver. TOTALLY UNEXPECTED. My sister found text messages on his phone. The lesbian in question already had 2 children (yes, i know.. not a very good lesbian) and was pregnant at the time she met my bro-in-law. The lesbian would show up at his work approximately once a week and get a check even though she was not employed there. He bought her a car and rented a house for her for a year (paid in advance).
Even when all of this came out my sister wanted to reconcile. At the first, counseling session he gets up after 15 minutes and says something like "Nope, not gonna happen!" and leaves. So her divorce lawyer requests financial documents from his business to decide alimony and child support. I forgot to mention they have 4 children together; the youngest of which is in college right now. Anyway, he didn't want to release any of the financial documents pertaining to this business so my sis says "Fine, I get the house and car and you get all the debt." He agreed to that which makes me want to know what he's trying to hide by not releasing the documents.
Anyway the divorce was just finalized and my sister is devastated. This is the only man she's ever been with. They met in college and now 28 years later....Nothing. The worst part is...If he asked her, I wouldn't be surprised if she took him back. I would lose all respect for her and do my best to talk her out of it.
It was a real shock. I know that divorce is common but not in my family. Mom and Dad were married 49 years before mom passed and none of my numerous siblings went through a divorce. Big Scandal.
My two favourites from working in a Legal Office:
Husband and wife get divorced, wife went into the marriage with her own house and three cars, him with nothing. She mortgaged the house in her name (as the bank wouldn't give her anything if his name was on it too) to let husband start a trucking business, buys all his trucks for him and pays off the mortgage herself. He becomes successful. They divorce, she just wants enough money from him to square her mortgage; he can have the business and everything else. He sells EVERYTHING to his friend for $10/next-to-nothing so that he's got nothing on his name and doesn't have to pay her squat. She's now going to lose the house.
2. Custody battle over two children. Father threatened the mother with a shotgun, cut her phone lines, got charged for assault on her. She flees town with the children. He demands she come back, and she agrees to visitation so the kids can see their father. During one visitation he punches her brother in the face at the changeover point and tries to steal the children. Visitation stops and he chucks a fit that she's "stealing his children" and "she's lying about being afraid of me! I did nothing!"
The Court psychologist signs off that he'd be an emotionally abusive sole parent. When the Court says "No" to his demands that he get sole custody, he verbally abuses the judge, his lawyer, his barrister, the psychologist, and the independent children's lawyer, IN FRONT of the entire Courtroom. He narrowly avoids arrest. And the whole time this case is going he's always yelling and screaming in the office that "The Court system is biased and only women get custody! It's a "Mummy's Court!" You're all sexist against men! Etc etc". No, you're just a Douche.
(EDITED BONUS) Man has wife and three kids, everything in his name. Finds a younger model. Dumps her by text message, changes the locks, and goes into hiding. Wife has a chronic illness that means she can't work, and now she's stuck with three kids, and to rub it in he's changed all the bills and payments to her name/mother's address and mailed her nearly $10,000 worth of accounts, and no one can find him.